Given situation
A sailor of mass $$m ext{s}$$ is standing on a light boat of mass $$m ext{b}$$ that is floating at rest with respect to the water and the nearby shore. The sailor suddenly jumps forward so as to land on the jetty.
We have to decide whether the boat will move, which way it will move and why.
Relevant principle — Newton’s third law
Whenever body A exerts a force on body B, body B simultaneously exerts an equal and opposite force on body A. In symbols
$$\vec F_{AB} = -\,\vec F_{BA}$$
Here the two bodies are
- the sailor (S)
- the boat (B).
The action–reaction pair while jumping
- To jump, the sailor pushes backward on the boat with a horizontal force $$\vec F_{\text{SB}}$$ (action).
- According to Newton’s third law, the boat exerts an equal and opposite force $$\vec F_{\text{BS}} = -\,\vec F_{\text{SB}}$$ on the sailor (reaction). This forward force on the sailor propels him toward the shore.
Effect on the boat
The force $$\vec F_{\text{SB}}$$ acting on the boat is unbalanced (no other horizontal forces of the same magnitude act on the boat, the water offers only a small drag). Hence, by Newton’s second law, the boat acquires an acceleration $$\vec a_{\text{b}}$$ given by
$$\vec a_{\text{b}} = \frac{\vec F_{\text{SB}}}{m_\text{b}}$$
Because $$\vec F_{\text{SB}}$$ is backward (opposite to the sailor’s intended motion), the boat accelerates and therefore moves backward, that is, opposite to the sailor’s jump.
Momentum method (optional verification)
Initially the boat–sailor system is at rest, so the total horizontal momentum is zero. Let the sailor leave the boat with speed $$u$$ relative to the shore in the forward direction. If the boat’s recoil speed is $$v$$ (opposite direction), conservation of linear momentum gives
$$m_\text{s} u - m_\text{b} v = 0 \;\;\Rightarrow\;\; v = \frac{m_\text{s}}{m_\text{b}}\,u$$
Since $$m_\text{b}$$ is usually larger than $$m_\text{s}$$, $$v$$ is smaller than $$u$$ but it is clearly non-zero and directed opposite to the sailor’s velocity, confirming that the boat must move backward when the sailor jumps forward.
Conclusion
Yes, the boat moves. It moves in the direction opposite to the sailor’s jump (i.e. backward, away from the shore) because while the sailor pushes the boat backward, the boat pushes the sailor forward; the backward push on the boat is unbalanced and sets it in motion.