PartΒ AΒ : A quick hands-on estimate
- Measure the diameter $$D$$ of the cotton reel as accurately as possible (use a ruler or, if available, a vernier calliper).
- Wrap a very thin thread tightly round the reel exactly 20 times, then unwind it and measure its total length $$L$$.
- The length that goes once round the reel is the circumference, so the experimental value of the circumference is $$\dfrac{L}{20}$$.
- The required ratio is therefore $$\dfrac{C}{D}=\dfrac{L}{20D}.$$
- A careful measurement usually gives $$\dfrac{L}{20D}\approx 3.14$$, which lies between $$3$$ and $$4$$ and more precisely between $$3.1$$ and $$3.2$$.
PartΒ BΒ : Obtaining the same bounds by pure geometry
We now show, without any measurement, that for every circle
\[3 \lt \dfrac{C}{D} \lt 4\qquad\text{and more precisely}\qquad 3.1 \lt \dfrac{C}{D} \lt 3.2.\]
1.Β Lower bound 3 β inscribed regular hexagon.
Draw a circle of centre $$O$$ and radius $$R$$, and inscribe a regular hexagon $$A_1A_2A_3A_4A_5A_6$$ in it. Each side of a regular hexagon inscribed in a circle equals the radius, so $$A_1A_2=A_2A_3=\dots =A_6A_1=R$$ and the perimeter of the hexagon is $$6R$$. A chord is always shorter than the arc it subtends, so the circumference $$C$$ exceeds the hexagonβs perimeter:
\[C \gt 6R.\]
Since $$D=2R$$,
\[\dfrac{C}{D} \gt \dfrac{6R}{2R}=3.\]
2.Β Upper bound 4 β circumscribed square.
Draw the smallest square that completely contains the circle; each side of this square equals the diameter $$D$$, so the perimeter of the square is $$4D$$. The circle lies entirely inside the square, and the circleβs circumference is shorter than the perimeter of any polygon that circumscribes it. Hence
\[C \lt 4D \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \dfrac{C}{D} \lt 4.\]
Combining the two bounds obtained so far,
\[3 \lt \dfrac{C}{D} \lt 4.\]
3.Β Sharper lower bound 3.105β¦ β inscribed regular dodecagon (12-gon).
The side of an inscribed regular $$n$$-gon is $$2R\sin\dfrac{180^{\circ}}{n}$$, so its perimeter is $$P_{\text{in}}=2nR\sin\dfrac{180^{\circ}}{n}$$. For $$n=12$$,
\[P_{\text{in}}=24R\sin 15^{\circ}.\]
Using $$\sin 15^{\circ}\approx 0.25882$$,
\[P_{\text{in}}\approx 24R\times 0.25882 \approx 6.2117\,R.\]
Hence
\[\dfrac{C}{D} \gt \dfrac{6.2117\,R}{2R}\approx 3.1058.\]
4.Β Sharper upper bound 3.215β¦ β circumscribed regular dodecagon.
The side of a regular $$n$$-gon circumscribing a circle of radius $$R$$ is $$2R\tan\dfrac{180^{\circ}}{n}$$, so its perimeter is $$P_{\text{out}}=2nR\tan\dfrac{180^{\circ}}{n}$$. For $$n=12$$,
\[P_{\text{out}}=24R\tan 15^{\circ}.\]
Using $$\tan 15^{\circ}\approx 0.26795$$,
\[P_{\text{out}}\approx 24R\times 0.26795 \approx 6.4308\,R.\]
Hence
\[\dfrac{C}{D} \lt \dfrac{6.4308\,R}{2R}\approx 3.2154.\]
5.Β Combining the refined bounds.
\[3.1058 \lt \dfrac{C}{D} \lt 3.2154,\]
which, rounded to one decimal place, gives
\[3.1 \lt \dfrac{C}{D} \lt 3.2.\]
Hence pure geometry, without any actual measurement, yields the same conclusion as the simple thread-and-reel experiment.