Step 1 – What is being observed?
When ice-cold water is poured in a glass tumbler, tiny drops of liquid water soon appear on the outer surface of the glass.
Step 2 – Could the drops have seeped through the glass?
Aavi guesses that water from inside might be oozing out. For this to be true, the water level inside the tumbler must go down.
Step 3 – Checking the water level (Thirav’s first reply)
After some time the inner level of water is observed carefully. No fall in the level can be detected with the naked eye. Glass is a continuous, non-porous solid, so ordinary liquid water cannot percolate through it.
Step 4 – “Perhaps the fall is too small to notice” (Aavi’s counter-point)
If the change really were too small to see in a wide tumbler, one should notice it in a tall, narrow bottle because the same volume loss would give a larger change in height.
Step 5 – Tall-bottle test (Thirav’s second reply)
Fill a long, slim glass bottle with the same ice-cold water, mark the initial water level with a permanent marker, and wait. The outer surface again becomes wet, yet the marked level inside the bottle remains unchanged. Hence no water is escaping through the walls.
Step 6 – Control experiment with room-temperature water
Now keep another tumbler containing water at ordinary room temperature next to the first one. Its outer surface stays perfectly dry. If seepage through glass were possible, both tumblers should show droplets, but only the cold one does. Therefore the droplets are not coming from inside.
Step 7 – Correct explanation: condensation of water vapour
Air always has invisible water vapour. The outside of the tumbler is cooled by the ice-cold water inside. When the warm, moist air touches this cold surface, it cools below the dew point; the water vapour present in the air loses heat and condenses into tiny liquid drops. These drops are what we see.
Step 8 – Verdict on each statement
- Aavi 1 – “Some water may have seeped out”: Not correct; glass is non-porous and the inside level does not fall.
- Thirav 1 – “No, it cannot seep out. The level has not decreased”: Correct.
- Aavi 2 – “The level might have decreased but not enough to be seen”: A fair doubt, but experiments (Steps 4 and 5) show no decrease even in a narrow bottle.
- Thirav 2 – “With a tall narrow bottle even a slight change is noticeable”: Right, and the experiment supports him.
- Thirav 3 – “Take room-temperature water in another tumbler as a test”: A good control that confirms the condensation explanation.
Conclusion
The water seen on the outer surface of a glass containing ice-cold water comes from the water vapour present in the surrounding air. It is condensation, not seepage through the glass.