Join WhatsApp Icon JEE WhatsApp Group
Question 57

Number of carbocations from the following that are not stabilized by hyperconjugation is __________

image

_


Correct Answer: 5

image

For a carbocation to be stabilized by hyperconjugation, it must possess at least one $$\alpha$$-hydrogen attached to an $$\text{sp}^3$$-hybridized carbon atom adjacent to the positively charged carbon:

$$\text{Stabilization by Hyperconjugation} \propto \text{Number of } \alpha\text{-hydrogens}$$


Individual Analysis of the 5 Carbocations:

  1. First Carbocation — Tris(tert-butyl)methyl cation, $$\text{C}^+\left(\text{C}(\text{CH}_3)_3\right)_3$$:

    The central positively charged carbon is bonded to three quaternary carbon atoms. Since these adjacent carbons have no hydrogen atoms directly attached to them, the number of $$\alpha$$-hydrogens is 0. It is not stabilized by hyperconjugation.

  2. Second Carbocation — Methyl cation, $$^+\text{CH}_3$$:

    There are no adjacent carbon atoms attached to the positive charge at all, meaning the number of $$\alpha$$-hydrogens is 0. It is not stabilized by hyperconjugation.

  3. Third Carbocation — Cyclopropenyl cation:

    This is a non-benzenoid aromatic system stabilized entirely by the delocalization of $$\pi$$-electrons (resonance). There are no adjacent $$\text{sp}^3$$ carbon atoms carrying hydrogen atoms, so the number of $$\alpha$$-hydrogens is 0. It is not stabilized by hyperconjugation.

  4. Fourth Carbocation — Methoxymethyl cation, $$^+\text{CH}_2\text{--O--CH}_3$$:

    The positive carbon is directly attached to an oxygen atom. It is exceptionally stabilized by back-bonding (resonance) from the lone pair of electrons on the oxygen atom. Because the adjacent atom is an oxygen rather than a carbon with hydrogens, it has 0 $$\alpha$$-hydrogens for hyperconjugation.

  5. Fifth Carbocation — Dimethylaminomethyl cation, $$(\text{CH}_3)_2\text{N--}^+\text{CH}_2$$:

    Similar to the fourth case, the positive charge is highly stabilized by the strong back-bonding/resonance from the lone pair of the adjacent nitrogen atom. The adjacent atom directly attached to the positive center is Nitrogen, giving it 0 $$\alpha$$-hydrogens for hyperconjugation.


Conclusion:

All five listed carbocations lack the necessary $$\alpha$$-hydrogens to undergo hyperconjugation stabilization, relying instead on inductive effects, resonance, or lone-pair back-bonding.

Answer: 5

Get AI Help

Video Solution

video

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests
Ask AI