Sign in
Please select an account to continue using cracku.in
↓ →
Join Our JEE Preparation Group
Prep with like-minded aspirants; Get access to free daily tests and study material.
The given reaction is the Finkelstein reaction, which proceeds through an $$S_N2$$ (bimolecular nucleophilic substitution) mechanism.
In this reaction, an alkyl bromide ($RCH_2Br$) reacts with an iodide ion ($I^-$) in the presence of acetone to form an alkyl iodide ($RCH_2I$).
Consider each statement individually.
For option (C):
Initially, the reactants consist of a neutral alkyl halide and a localized iodide ion ($I^-$), where the entire negative charge resides on a single iodine atom.
During the $$S_N2$$ reaction, the nucleophile attacks the carbon atom while the leaving group departs simultaneously, producing the transition state
$$[I^{\delta-}\cdots CH_2(R)\cdots Br^{\delta-}]^{\ddagger}.$$
In this transition state, the negative charge is distributed over the incoming iodine atom, the central carbon atom, and the leaving bromine atom rather than being localized on a single atom.
As a result, the transition state has a lower charge density and is therefore less polar than the isolated iodide ion.
Hence, statement (C) is correct.
For option (A):
In the Finkelstein reaction, acetone dissolves sodium iodide but not sodium bromide.
As the reaction proceeds,
$$NaBr$$
precipitates out of the solution, removing $$Br^-$$ ions from the reaction mixture.
Therefore, $$Br^-$$ cannot effectively act as a competing nucleophile.
Hence, statement (A) is incorrect.
For option (B):
Acetic acid is a polar protic solvent.
Polar protic solvents strongly solvate nucleophilic anions such as $$I^-$$ through hydrogen bonding, significantly reducing their nucleophilicity and slowing the $$S_N2$$ reaction.
The Finkelstein reaction requires a polar aprotic solvent such as acetone.
Hence, statement (B) is incorrect.
For option (D):
Acetone is a polar aprotic solvent and does not strongly solvate anions because it cannot form hydrogen bonds with them.
Moreover, the rate-determining step involves a transition state rather than freely solvated ions.
Therefore, the statement that the solvent solvates the ions formed in the rate-determining step is incorrect.
Hence, statement (D) is incorrect.
Therefore, the only correct statement is
(C) The transition state is less polar than the iodide ion.
Create a FREE account and get:
Educational materials for JEE preparation