Sign in
Please select an account to continue using cracku.in
↓ →
Which investment gives a better return, assuming the face value of shares to be Rs. 10?
A. 5% stock at 75, subject to 30% income tax
B. 4% stock at 90, tax free
A says that, for an investment of Rs. 75, the return will be 5% on Rs. 10, with a 30% tax.
So, Total return= $$\ \frac{\ 5}{100\ }\cdot10$$.
After tax deduction, Final Return= $$\ \frac{\ 5}{100\ }\cdot10\cdot\ \frac{\ 70}{100}$$ = 0.35
Percentage return= $$\ \frac{\ 0.35}{75}\cdot100$$= $$\ \frac{\ 35}{75}$$= 0.467%
B says that, for an investment of Rs. 90, the return will be 4% on Rs. 10, tax free.
So, Total return= $$\ \frac{\ 4}{100}\cdot10$$ =0.4
Percentage return for B= $$\ \frac{\ 0.4}{90}\cdot100$$= $$\ \frac{\ 40}{90}$$= 0.444%
Since, Percentage return in case A is greater than that in case B. Therefore, Option B is correct.
Create a FREE account and get:
Book Free CAT Mentorship
Get personalized CAT strategy from a 99%iler
500+ students mentored
OTP Verification
Enter the 6-digit code sent to your phone
Booking Summary
Enter OTP
Didn't receive the OTP?
Start your IIM journey with the right preparation and crack CAT 2026.
Educational materials for CAT preparation