Join WhatsApp Icon JEE WhatsApp Group
Question 45

Liquid M and liquid N form an ideal solution. The vapour pressures of pure liquids M and N are 450 and 700 mmHg, respectively, at the same temperature. Then correct statements is:
(x$$_M$$ = Mole fraction of 'M' in solution; x$$_N$$ = Mole fraction of 'N' in solution; y$$_M$$ = Mole fraction of 'M' in vapour phase; y$$_N$$ = Mole fraction of 'N' in vapour phase)

We begin by recalling Raoult’s law for an ideal binary solution. It states:

$$P_M = x_M\,P_M^{\!*} \quad\text{and}\quad P_N = x_N\,P_N^{\!*}$$

where $$P_M$$ and $$P_N$$ are the partial vapour pressures of components $$M$$ and $$N$$, $$x_M$$ and $$x_N$$ are their mole fractions in the liquid phase, and $$P_M^{\!*}$$ and $$P_N^{\!*}$$ are the vapour pressures of the pure liquids at the same temperature.

We are given:

$$P_M^{\!*}=450\;\text{mmHg}, \qquad P_N^{\!*}=700\;\text{mmHg}$$

Now the total vapour pressure of the solution is the sum of the partial pressures:

$$P_{\text{total}} = P_M + P_N = x_M P_M^{\!*} + x_N P_N^{\!*} = 450\,x_M + 700\,x_N$$

The mole fraction of each component in the vapour phase is obtained from Dalton’s law of partial pressures:

$$y_M = \frac{P_M}{P_{\text{total}}}, \qquad y_N = \frac{P_N}{P_{\text{total}}}$$

Substituting the expressions for $$P_M$$ and $$P_N$$ just found, we get

$$y_M = \frac{x_M P_M^{\!*}}{x_M P_M^{\!*} + x_N P_N^{\!*}} = \frac{450\,x_M}{450\,x_M + 700\,x_N}$$

and

$$y_N = \frac{x_N P_N^{\!*}}{x_M P_M^{\!*} + x_N P_N^{\!*}} = \frac{700\,x_N}{450\,x_M + 700\,x_N}$$

We now form the ratio of the vapour-phase mole fractions:

$$\frac{y_M}{y_N} \;=\; \frac{ \dfrac{450\,x_M}{450\,x_M + 700\,x_N} }{ \dfrac{700\,x_N}{450\,x_M + 700\,x_N} }$$

The common denominator $$450\,x_M + 700\,x_N$$ cancels out, leaving

$$\frac{y_M}{y_N} = \frac{450\,x_M}{700\,x_N}$$

We separate the numerical factor from the mole-fraction ratio:

$$\frac{y_M}{y_N} = \frac{450}{700}\;\frac{x_M}{x_N}$$

The fraction $$\frac{450}{700}$$ simplifies to $$\frac{9}{14}$$, and numerically it equals $$0.642857\ldots$$ which is clearly less than $$1$$. Thus

$$\frac{y_M}{y_N} = \left(\frac{9}{14}\right)\frac{x_M}{x_N}$$

Because $$\dfrac{9}{14} < 1$$, the above equation can be rearranged to

$$\frac{x_M}{x_N} > \frac{y_M}{y_N}$$

This inequality is independent of the actual composition (as long as $$0 < x_M, x_N < 1$$ and $$x_M + x_N = 1$$). Therefore, the correct qualitative statement among the given options is

$$\frac{x_M}{x_N} > \frac{y_M}{y_N}$$

This corresponds to Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Get AI Help

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests

50,000+ JEE Students Trusted Our Score Calculator

Predict your JEE Main percentile, rank & performance in seconds

Ask AI

Ask our AI anything

AI can make mistakes. Please verify important information.