Join WhatsApp Icon JEE WhatsApp Group
Question 33

An organic compound 'A' $$(C_9H_{10}O)$$ when treated with conc. HI undergoes cleavage to yield compound 'B' and 'C'. 'B' gives yellow precipitate with $$AgNO_3$$ where as 'C' tautomerizes to 'D'. 'D' gives positive iodoform test. 'A' could be:

1. Finding Compound 'B' (Yellow Precipitate with AgNO3) When an ether is cleaved with concentrated hydroiodic acid (HI), it breaks into an alcohol/phenol and an alkyl iodide.

  • The problem states that compound 'B' gives a yellow precipitate when treated with silver nitrate (AgNO3).
  • This tells us that 'B' is an iodide compound that can easily form a stable carbocation to release the iodide ion (I-), which reacts with silver ions to form silver iodide (AgI, a yellow ppt).
  • Benzyl iodide (C6H5-CH2-I) forms a highly stable benzyl carbocation via resonance, making it extremely reactive toward AgNO3. Therefore, 'B' is Benzyl iodide.

2. Finding Compound 'C' and 'D' (Tautomerization and Iodoform Test)

  • The other product formed during the cleavage is compound 'C'.
  • The question states that 'C' tautomerizes to 'D', and 'D' gives a positive iodoform test.
  • For a compound to give a positive iodoform test, it must contain a methyl ketone group (CH3-C=O) or an alcohol that can be oxidized to a methyl ketone.
  • If 'C' tautomerizes to a methyl ketone, 'C' must be an enol (specifically, vinyl alcohol: CH2=CH-OH).
  • Vinyl alcohol ('C') tautomerizes to Acetaldehyde ('D', CH3-CHO), which contains the necessary methyl group adjacent to the carbonyl carbon to give a positive iodoform test.

The Reaction Protocol for Option C

Let's test Option C: C6H5-CH2-O-CH=CH2 (Benzyl vinyl ether)

Step A: Cleavage with conc. HI The oxygen atom gets protonated, and the iodide ion attacks the benzyl group because the benzyl carbocation is highly stable (or passes through a favorable SN1/SN2 pathway).

  • C6H5-CH2-O-CH=CH2 + HI ---> C6H5-CH2-I (Compound B) + CH2=CH-OH (Compound C)

Step B: Testing Compound B

  • C6H5-CH2-I + AgNO3 ---> AgI (Yellow Precipitate) + C6H5-CH2-ONO2

Step C: Tautomerization of Compound C

  • CH2=CH-OH (Enol form 'C') ---> CH3-CHO (Keto/Aldehyde form 'D')

Step D: Iodoform Test on Compound D

  • CH3-CHO + 3 I2 + 4 NaOH ---> CHI3 (Iodoform yellow ppt) + HCOONa + 3 NaI + 3 H2O

This perfectly satisfies every single condition in the question.

Why the Other Options are Incorrect

  • Option A (C6H5-O-CH2-CH=CH2): Cleavage with HI would break the aliphatic bond because the phenyl-oxygen bond (C6H5-O) has partial double-bond character due to resonance and cannot be easily broken. This would yield Phenol (C6H5-OH) and Allyl Iodide (CH2=CH-CH2-I). Neither of these products can tautomerize to give a positive iodoform test.
  • Option B (C6H5-O-CH=CH-CH3): Cleavage with HI yields Phenol (C6H5-OH) and Propen-1-ol (CH3-CH=CH-OH). While Propen-1-ol tautomerizes to Propanal (CH3-CH2-CHO), Propanal does not have a CH3-C=O group and will fail the iodoform test.
  • Option D (CH3-C6H4-O-CH=CH2): Cleavage with HI yields p-Cresol (CH3-C6H4-OH) and Vinyl alcohol (CH2=CH-OH). Vinyl alcohol would form Acetaldehyde and pass the iodoform test, but p-Cresol will not react with AgNO3 to give a yellow precipitate because the iodine would have to attach directly to the benzene ring (aryl iodide), which does not readily undergo substitution to release iodide ions.

Get AI Help

Video Solution

video

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests
Ask AI