Question 31

The correct order of ionic radii for the ions, P$$^{3-}$$, S$$^{2-}$$, Ca$$^{2+}$$, K$$^+$$, Cl$$^-$$ is:

First, let us note the atomic numbers of the parent atoms: $$\text P\,(Z=15),\; \text S\,(Z=16),\; \text{Cl}\,(Z=17),\; \text K\,(Z=19),\; \text{Ca}\,(Z=20).$$

Now we write the electronic population of each given ion. We subtract or add electrons according to the charge:

$$\begin{aligned} \text P^{3-}: &\; 15+3 = 18 \text{ electrons},\\ \text S^{2-}: &\; 16+2 = 18 \text{ electrons},\\ \text{Cl}^-: &\; 17+1 = 18 \text{ electrons},\\ \text K^+: &\; 19-1 = 18 \text{ electrons},\\ \text{Ca}^{2+}: &\; 20-2 = 18 \text{ electrons}. \end{aligned}$$

So every species possesses exactly $$18$$ electrons. Such a group is called an isoelectronic series.

For an isoelectronic series, we apply the rule: “When the number of electrons is the same, the ionic radius decreases as the nuclear charge $$Z$$ increases.” The reason is that a greater positive charge in the nucleus pulls the same electron cloud more strongly, producing a smaller radius. Symbolically we can write

$$\text{larger } Z \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{larger } Z_{\text{eff}} \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{smaller radius}.$$

Hence we simply arrange the ions in order of increasing atomic number (increasing $$Z$$) to obtain decreasing radius. Starting with the smallest atomic number 15 and moving upward:

$$Z=15 \;(\text P^{3-}) \gt Z=16 \;(\text S^{2-}) \gt Z=17 \;(\text{Cl}^-) \gt Z=19 \;(\text K^+) \gt Z=20 \;(\text{Ca}^{2+}).$$

Thus the descending order of ionic radii is

$$\text P^{3-} \gt \text S^{2-} \gt \text{Cl}^- \gt \text K^+ \gt \text{Ca}^{2+}.$$

When we match this sequence with the listed alternatives, we see that it coincides exactly with Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Was this solution helpful?

Get AI Help

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests
Ask AI