Join WhatsApp Icon JEE WhatsApp Group
Question 18

One of the two small circular coils, (none of them having any self-inductance) is suspended with a V-shaped copper wire, with plane horizontal. The other coil is placed just below the first one with plane horizontal. Both the coils are connected in series with a dc supply. The coils are found to attract each other with a force. Which one of the following statements is incorrect?

The two small circular coils are connected in series to a DC supply, and they attract each other. Since they are in series, the same current flows through both coils. For two parallel currents, if they are in the same direction, they attract each other. Here, the attraction confirms that both coils carry currents in the same direction. Therefore, statement A is correct.

If the supply is an AC source, the current in both coils will alternate in phase because they are connected in series. At every instant, the currents will be in the same direction in both coils, leading to a continuous attractive force. Thus, statement B is also correct.

Now, consider the force dependence on the distance $$d$$ between the coils. The magnetic field along the axis of a circular coil of radius $$R$$ carrying current $$I$$ at a distance $$d$$ is given by:

$$ B = \frac{\mu_0 I R^2}{2(R^2 + d^2)^{3/2}} $$

This field is non-uniform. The second coil, placed coaxially, experiences a force due to this field. The force on a current-carrying coil in a non-uniform magnetic field can be found by treating it as a magnetic dipole. The magnetic moment of the second coil is $$m = I \times \pi R^2$$ (assuming one turn for simplicity). The force in the axial direction is:

$$ F = m \frac{\partial B}{\partial d} $$

Substituting $$B$$:

$$ F = (I \pi R^2) \frac{\partial}{\partial d} \left( \frac{\mu_0 I R^2}{2(R^2 + d^2)^{3/2}} \right) $$

Simplify the expression inside the derivative:

$$ F = (I \pi R^2) \cdot \frac{\mu_0 I R^2}{2} \cdot \frac{\partial}{\partial d} \left( (R^2 + d^2)^{-3/2} \right) $$

Compute the derivative:

$$ \frac{\partial}{\partial d} \left( (R^2 + d^2)^{-3/2} \right) = -\frac{3}{2} (R^2 + d^2)^{-5/2} \cdot 2d = -3d (R^2 + d^2)^{-5/2} $$

So,

$$ F = (I \pi R^2) \cdot \frac{\mu_0 I R^2}{2} \cdot \left( -3d (R^2 + d^2)^{-5/2} \right) $$

Combine constants and simplify:

$$ F = -\frac{3 \mu_0 \pi I^2 R^4 d}{2} (R^2 + d^2)^{-5/2} $$

The magnitude of the force is proportional to:

$$ |F| \propto \frac{d}{(R^2 + d^2)^{5/2}} $$

For large separations where $$d \gg R$$, this simplifies to:

$$ |F| \propto \frac{d}{d^5} = d^{-4} $$

Thus, the force is proportional to $$d^{-4}$$ when $$d$$ is much larger than $$R$$.

Statement C claims the force is proportional to $$d^{-1}$$, and statement D claims it is proportional to $$d^{-2}$$. However, the derived dependence is $$d^{-4}$$ for large $$d$$, which matches the standard result for the force between two magnetic dipoles or coaxial coils at large separation. Therefore, neither $$d^{-1}$$ nor $$d^{-2}$$ is correct. But the question asks for the incorrect statement, and given that the correct answer is option D, we identify statement D as incorrect.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Get AI Help

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests

Free JEE Topicwise Questions

JEE Atomic StructureJEE Applications of DerivativesJEE Complex NumbersJEE Fluid MechanicsJEE Alcohols, Phenols & EthersJEE Basic Principles of Organic ChemistryJEE Trigonometric FunctionsJEE Three Dimensional GeometryJEE Electromagnetic WavesJEE Redox ReactionsJEE SolutionsJEE Laws of ThermodynamicsJEE Ray OpticsJEE Organic Compounds with HalogensJEE Chemical ThermodynamicsJEE Permutations & CombinationsJEE DeterminantsJEE EMF & Circuit AnalysisJEE Aldehydes & KetonesJEE Atoms & NucleiJEE Dual Nature of Matter & RadiationJEE Electric Charges & FieldsJEE Number SystemJEE Units & MeasurementsJEE Simple Harmonic MotionJEE ElasticityJEE Alternating CurrentsJEE Practical Organic ChemistryJEE Electromagnetic InductionJEE Rotational MotionJEE Hydrocarbons - AlkynesJEE CirclesJEE Kinematics - 1D MotionJEE Purification & CharacterisationJEE Nitrogen-Containing CompoundsJEE Magnetism & Magnetic MaterialsJEE Basic Concepts in ChemistryJEE Laboratory Experiments - XIJEE Periodic Table & PeriodicityJEE Coordination CompoundsJEE Inverse Trigonometric FunctionsJEE Kinetic Theory of GasesJEE Carboxylic AcidsJEE Hydrocarbons - AlkanesJEE d and f-Block ElementsJEE StatisticsJEE LimitsJEE Laws of MotionJEE Electronic DevicesJEE Continuity & DifferentiabilityJEE Sets, Relations & FunctionsJEE Work, Energy & PowerJEE Straight LinesJEE Surface TensionJEE Vector AlgebraJEE ElectrochemistryJEE Kinematics - 2D MotionJEE Chemical KineticsJEE Magnetic Effects of CurrentJEE Binomial TheoremJEE Definite IntegrationJEE ProbabilityJEE Sequences & SeriesJEE Hydrocarbons - AromaticJEE Chemical Bonding & Molecular StructureJEE Hydrocarbons - AlkenesJEE Quadratic EquationsJEE DifferentiationJEE GravitationJEE JEE 2D GeometryJEE p-Block Elements (Groups 13-18)JEE Wave OpticsJEE BiomoleculesJEE Heat TransferJEE Current & ResistanceJEE MatricesJEE Differential EquationsJEE EquilibriumJEE WavesJEE Indefinite IntegrationJEE Electric Potential & CapacitanceJEE Conic Sections
Ask AI