Question 28

Hydrogen ($$_1H^1$$), Deuterium ($$_1H^2$$), singly ionised Helium ($$_2He^4$$)$$^+$$ and doubly ionised lithium ($$_3Li^6$$)$$^{++}$$ all have one electron around the nucleus. Consider an electron transition from $$n = 2$$ to $$n = 1$$. If the wave lengths of emitted radiation are $$\lambda_1$$, $$\lambda_2$$, $$\lambda_3$$ and $$\lambda_4$$ respectively then approximately which one of the following is correct?

For every hydrogen-like species the electron energy in the Bohr model is written first: $$E_n = -\,13.6\;\text{eV}\;\dfrac{Z^2}{n^2},$$ where $$Z$$ is the atomic number and $$n$$ is the principal quantum number. The transition energy from level $$n_2$$ to level $$n_1$$ is then $$\Delta E = E_{n_1}-E_{n_2} = -13.6\,\text{eV}\,Z^2\!\left(\dfrac{1}{n_1^{\,2}}-\dfrac{1}{n_2^{\,2}}\right).$$

Bohr also gives the wave-number formula $$\dfrac{1}{\lambda} = R\,Z^2\!\left(\dfrac{1}{n_1^{\,2}}-\dfrac{1}{n_2^{\,2}}\right),$$ where $$R$$ is the Rydberg constant. Since the present question asks only for ratios of wavelengths, we may use the proportionality $$\lambda \propto \dfrac{1}{Z^2}\;\;(\text{for given }n_1,n_2).$$ The difference between hydrogen and deuterium comes only from the reduced mass, which changes $$R$$ by about 0.05 %, far smaller than the integer ratios we are comparing, so we shall treat the two $$Z = 1$$ nuclei as giving the same wavelength.

We are concerned with the transition $$n_2 = 2 \rightarrow n_1 = 1$$, so the factor $$\left(\dfrac{1}{1^2}-\dfrac{1}{2^2}\right)=\dfrac{3}{4}$$ is the same for all four species. Therefore, denoting the wavelengths by $$\lambda_1$$ for $$_1H^1$$, $$\lambda_2$$ for $$_1H^2$$, $$\lambda_3$$ for $$_2He^4{}^+$$ and $$\lambda_4$$ for $$_3Li^6{}^{++}$$, we have

$$\lambda_1 \;:\;\lambda_2 \;:\;\lambda_3 \;:\;\lambda_4 \;=\;\dfrac{1}{Z_1^{\,2}}\;:\;\dfrac{1}{Z_2^{\,2}}\;:\;\dfrac{1}{Z_3^{\,2}}\;:\;\dfrac{1}{Z_4^{\,2}} \;=\;\dfrac{1}{1^{2}}\;:\;\dfrac{1}{1^{2}}\;:\;\dfrac{1}{2^{2}}\;:\;\dfrac{1}{3^{2}}.$$ Simplifying each denominator we obtain

$$\lambda_1 : \lambda_2 : \lambda_3 : \lambda_4 = 1 : 1 : \dfrac{1}{4} : \dfrac{1}{9}.$$

To express all four as integers, multiply every term by 36 (the LCM of 1, 4 and 9):

$$36\lambda_1 : 36\lambda_2 : 36\lambda_3 : 36\lambda_4 = 36 : 36 : 9 : 4.$$

Dividing each of these four numbers by 4 gives a cleaner ratio:

$$9\lambda_1 : 9\lambda_2 : 9\lambda_3 : 9\lambda_4 = 9 : 9 : 2.25 : 1.$$

It is clearer, however, to leave the ratio in its simplest fractional form, matching it directly to one of the given options:

$$\lambda_1 = \lambda_2 = 4\lambda_3 = 9\lambda_4.$$

Comparing with the options supplied in the problem statement, this equality is precisely the one written in Option C. Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Was this solution helpful?

Get AI Help

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests
Ask AI