Join WhatsApp Icon JEE WhatsApp Group
Question 13

Two ions of masses 4 amu and 16 amu have charges +2e and +3e respectively. These ions pass through the region of the constant perpendicular magnetic field. The kinetic energy of both ions is the same. Then:

We have two ions that both enter a region where the magnetic field $$\vec B$$ is uniform and perpendicular to their velocities. Whenever a charged particle moves perpendicular to a magnetic field, it describes a circular path. The required formula for the radius of that circular path is first recalled:

For a particle of mass $$m$$, charge $$q$$ and speed $$v$$ in a magnetic field of magnitude $$B$$ (with velocity perpendicular to the field), the magnetic force provides the necessary centripetal force. Hence

$$q\,v\,B = \dfrac{m v^{2}}{r}.$$

Solving this equation for the radius $$r$$ gives

$$r = \dfrac{m\,v}{q\,B} \;.$$

In the present question, both ions possess the same kinetic energy. Let us denote that common kinetic energy by $$K$$. The kinetic energy of any particle is related to its speed by the well-known relation

$$K = \dfrac{1}{2} m v^{2}.$$

From this we can express the speed $$v$$ of each ion in terms of its mass and the common kinetic energy:

$$v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2K}{m}}.$$

Now we substitute this expression for $$v$$ into the radius formula. Performing the substitution, we get

$$r = \dfrac{m}{q\,B}\;\sqrt{\dfrac{2K}{m}}.$$

By taking the square root of $$m$$ in the numerator, the algebraic simplification proceeds as follows:

$$r = \dfrac{\sqrt{m}\;\sqrt{m}}{q\,B}\;\sqrt{\dfrac{2K}{m}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{m}\;}{q\,B}\;\sqrt{2K} = \dfrac{\sqrt{2K}}{B}\;\dfrac{\sqrt{m}}{q}.$$

The magnetic field $$B$$ and the factor $$\sqrt{2K}$$ are identical for both ions, so the only quantity that decides the relative radii is the ratio $$\dfrac{\sqrt{m}}{q}$$.

Let us calculate this ratio for each ion separately.

Ion 1 (lighter ion)
Mass $$m_{1}=4\ \text{amu},\qquad q_{1}=+2e.$$

$$\dfrac{\sqrt{m_{1}}}{q_{1}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{4}}{2e} = \dfrac{2}{2e} = \dfrac{1}{e}.$$

Ion 2 (heavier ion)
Mass $$m_{2}=16\ \text{amu},\qquad q_{2}=+3e.$$

$$\dfrac{\sqrt{m_{2}}}{q_{2}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{16}}{3e} = \dfrac{4}{3e}.$$

We now compare these two numerical factors:

$$\dfrac{\sqrt{m_{2}}}{q_{2}} = \dfrac{4}{3e}\;>\;\dfrac{1}{e} = \dfrac{\sqrt{m_{1}}}{q_{1}}.$$

The radius of curvature is directly proportional to this factor, so

$$r_{2} > r_{1}.$$

Because the heavier ion (Ion 2) travels in a circle of larger radius, it is bent less sharply by the magnetic field. Conversely, the lighter ion (Ion 1) follows a circle of smaller radius, meaning its trajectory bends more.

In ordinary language, a smaller radius corresponds to greater deflection; a larger radius corresponds to less deflection. Therefore the lighter ion is deflected more, and the heavier ion is deflected less.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Get AI Help

Create a FREE account and get:

  • Free JEE Mains Previous Papers PDF
  • Take JEE Mains paper tests

50,000+ JEE Students Trusted Our Score Calculator

Predict your JEE Main percentile, rank & performance in seconds

Ask AI

Ask our AI anything

AI can make mistakes. Please verify important information.