Join WhatsApp Icon IPMAT WhatsApp Group
Question 41

A club applies the following five rules to its members.
1. Every member who coaches also umpires.
2. Every member on the finance panel pays a levy.
3. No umpire is on the finance panel.
4. No member who pays a levy umpires.
5. No member on the finance panel coaches.
Which one of the following rules is/are redundant given the other rules?
(I) Rule 3
(II) Rule 5

From Rules 2 and 4, a finance-panel member pays a levy and therefore does not umpire, which is exactly Rule 3, so Rule 3 is redundant. Further, a finance-panel member does not umpire, and by Rule 1 anyone who coaches must umpire, so such a member cannot coach, which is Rule 5. Rule 5 therefore follows from Rules 1, 2 and 4, and both rules are redundant.

Was this solution helpful?

Get AI Help

Over 8000+ registered students have benefitted from Cracku's IPMAT Course

Crack IPMAT 2026 with Cracku

Ask AI