In my opinion, the psychological thrillers of Alfred Hitchcock, who is a master of suspense and horror, have more lasting impact than any other filmmaker in history.

The given sentence compares films of Hitchcock [... psychological thrillers of Alfred Hitchcock"] with filmmakers["...than any other filmmaker"] , which is illogical. The comparison should be between like things; in this case, it should be between films of the filmmakers. Also, the use of  "have" (present simple) is less precise than "have had" (present perfect) for an ongoing impact over time.

Keeping these in mind, we see that only Option D satisfies all these, and hence it is the correct choice.